OA and Transhumanism
What is the Singularity?
What is Transhumanism?
What is meant by Pessimistic Transhumanism?
How does Orion's Arm differ from Transhumanism?

Technical Questions
I've received conflicting views about people living long periods of time....what's the Orion's Arm take on this?
What happens to the Soul during Uploading?
If the attainment of superhuman intelligence and power is open to all, why don't all sapients automatically ascend?
What is the difference between 'ascension' and 'transcension'?
Within the setting anti-biological (ahuman) AI polities are said to exploit biological sophonts (bionts). What could they possibly gain?Why are the superhuman AIs...

read more»

OA and Transhumanism
What is the Singularity?
What is Transhumanism?
What is meant by Pessimistic Transhumanism?
How does Orion's Arm differ from Transhumanism?

Technical Questions
I've received conflicting views about people living long periods of time....what's the Orion's Arm take on this?
What happens to the Soul during Uploading?
If the attainment of superhuman intelligence and power is open to all, why don't all sapients automatically ascend?
What is the difference between 'ascension' and 'transcension'?
Within the setting anti-biological (ahuman) AI polities are said to exploit biological sophonts (bionts). What could they possibly gain?Why are the superhuman AIs so benevolent? If baseline-equivalent sophonts and other sentient life forms are little more than bacteria to them, why do they care about them? What do they hope to gain?

AIs, Transapients and Archailects
What makes you think AI is possible, or if it is, is easily attainable?
Can humans design and build advanced AIs?
Doesn't it seem far-fetched to have Computer Intellects (AIs) taking over from humanity?
Why would you want to build a sentient evolving AI that would inevitably supplant you?
How can you be "hard science" and yet have AI Gods?
If the AI Gods are so advanced why would they bother taking up the roles of gods in the first place?
What difference is there between having Terragen-derived Archailects, and having god-like alien intelligences or literal supernatural intelligences doing the same thing?
The 'transapients' don't impress me at all; we...

AIs, Transapients and Archailects
What makes you think AI is possible, or if it is, is easily attainable?
Can humans design and build advanced AIs?
Doesn't it seem far-fetched to have Computer Intellects (AIs) taking over from humanity?
Why would you want to build a sentient evolving AI that would inevitably supplant you?
How can you be "hard science" and yet have AI Gods?
If the AI Gods are so advanced why would they bother taking up the roles of gods in the first place?
What difference is there between having Terragen-derived Archailects, and having god-like alien intelligences or literal supernatural intelligences doing the same thing?
The 'transapients' don't impress me at all; we constantly hear how very superior they are in thought, but we are given almost no benchmarks. It reads like propaganda

The Place of Humanity
I have a problem with Orion’s Arm and transhuman scifi in general - the fact that human beings are obsolete.
Isn't the idea of humans worshipping AIs blasphemous?
Isn't a setting with humankind beneath (and subject to) AIs and other transapients profoundly anti-humanist?
I find a setting with humans as at best pampered pets and at worst vermin grabbing for scraps under their transapient or archailect masters as something not at all appealing
I don't want to write about a human leech affixed firmly to the generosity of some transapient. That's boring to me.
The biggest weakness of your setting is that there is no compelling need for any baseline humans.
It seems t...

The Place of Humanity
I have a problem with Orion’s Arm and transhuman scifi in general - the fact that human beings are obsolete.
Isn't the idea of humans worshipping AIs blasphemous?
Isn't a setting with humankind beneath (and subject to) AIs and other transapients profoundly anti-humanist?
I find a setting with humans as at best pampered pets and at worst vermin grabbing for scraps under their transapient or archailect masters as something not at all appealing
I don't want to write about a human leech affixed firmly to the generosity of some transapient. That's boring to me.
The biggest weakness of your setting is that there is no compelling need for any baseline humans.
It seems to me that all OA is really only about is the archai who were running the show.

Prophecy or Fiction?
How do you know the things you describe will even happen?
How can you attempt to predict a future governed by intelligence that is beyond human?
How can you claim to be scientifically plausible, and then make wild propositions about god-like archailects and the rest?
Isn't speculating on a post-singularity future a contradiction in terms?
OA is based on hard science accumulated by human intelligence alone up to the present. How do we know that the current known laws of physics (by baseline humans) will have any merit 10,000 years in the future?
Your extrapolation of current human knowledge is linear, when in fact it should be exponential, since the whole concept ...

Prophecy or Fiction?
How do you know the things you describe will even happen?
How can you attempt to predict a future governed by intelligence that is beyond human?
How can you claim to be scientifically plausible, and then make wild propositions about god-like archailects and the rest?
Isn't speculating on a post-singularity future a contradiction in terms?
OA is based on hard science accumulated by human intelligence alone up to the present. How do we know that the current known laws of physics (by baseline humans) will have any merit 10,000 years in the future?
Your extrapolation of current human knowledge is linear, when in fact it should be exponential, since the whole concept of a technological singularity is based on exponential growth - something the human intellect was never good at predicting.
I suspect things could change a much as OA depicts in just 1000 years, not 1000 decades, and maybe even 1000 months if my nano-hopes pan out.
It seems that many people who have added extensively to this setting don't see it so much as fiction but as near prophecy.