Clipmarks
   
  
   
willhelmfollowshare
2-22-2008 4:11 PM431 views
20 Comments   | Add a Comment
2-22-2008 4:32 PM
boniface
Christianity and Islam are religions that insist on converting the whole world to their belief. What people, in all religions, must realize is that never will all the people on the planet belong to one faith. There are just too many different points-of-view for that to happen.

Once this realization is apparent, we can see that the only way for peace to occur on our planet, is to be tolerant of differences, not only of religion, but thought as well. Even the bible says, "not all will be saved," so, I wish they would stop the conversion attempts. If you think you are saved, then bully for you christians and muslims, have a little tolerance for those of us who don't wish to be, at least, not by your standards.
2-22-2008 4:46 PM
willhelm
Where can you point to an example of Christians attempting to "convert"? Christians engage in good works, charity, and spreading the truth of the gospel to those willing to listen. There is no force. There is no demand. There is no intolerance. There is only a peaceful expression of faith.

On the other hand, and partially the point of the clip, is the misunderstanding of what tolerance means. The growing tide of intolerance is heavily weighted on the side of secularists, humanists, and atheists.

From clip:
"You cannot be tolerant of something unless you object to it"
2-22-2008 4:51 PM
bignosemousie
Today, “tolerance” has made passing judgment unfashionable on many attitudes and behaviors.
Great clip, Willhelm.
2-22-2008 4:52 PM
arifsali
Pop for boniface's comment.
2-22-2008 4:53 PM
arifsali
Where can you point to an example of Christians attempting to "convert"?
willhelm, you got to be kidding
2-22-2008 4:55 PM
arifsali
To avoid judgment is not to be sensitive or tolerant. It is to avoid responsibility.
There's got to be ten thousand verses in all scriptures combined asking seekers to not be judgmental.
2-22-2008 4:56 PM
arifsali
On Christian "Hate"
Can you build a context for the heading of your clip with the text you have clipped? I'm not sure what you mean by On Christian Hate.
2-22-2008 5:09 PM
willhelm
First, Arifasi, judgment in this context means discernment.

Second, The Word of God impels us to make good judgement. The verses that point to disapproval of judement relate to our inability to condemn. That is the biblical point that this clip affirms. - You cannot tolerate unless you object. Objection is not condemnation.
That is what makes us human and points to our unique nature of free will.

Third, Regarding conversion, give me an example. Even the example atheists like to use, The Crusades, had absolutely not ONE THING to do with converting non-believers. ( Regarding this point, I will not deny there may have been some in history that have practiced forceful zeal. However, this is no...
2-22-2008 5:56 PM
arifsali
Regarding conversion, give me an example.
Here, wouldn't take you long to get to the point.
2-22-2008 6:18 PM
boniface
@willhelm

" Where can you point to an example of Christians attempting to "convert"?"
Yep, "missionaries."
2-22-2008 7:08 PM
willhelm
Perhaps you might want to think more deeply about the words you are
using rather than suppose you know what they mean. That is what this
clip was about in terms of tolerance. You could continue this process
on a deeper understanding of the term conversion. If you had an
understanding of Christian theology it might lead to question whether
conversion is possible. In the way you are applying the term,
conversion is not possible. For example, One understanding Christian
theology would dismiss "conversion" as an impossibility.
Yep, "missionaries."
See? Now that is an intolarant and hateful suggestion that is borne of ignorance.


You find it perfectly fine for yourself to have an ...
2-23-2008 2:22 AM
boniface
@willhelm
"You find it perfectly fine for yourself to have an opinion and demand others live by it as in your initial comment."
I'm not demanding anyone live by my opinion. It's just an opinion. You asked for one example of Christians trying to convert others. I gave you the example. That's all.
2-23-2008 2:39 AM
willhelm
I am sorry, boniface. I just want to make it clear that missionaries do not "convert". Christians recognize that it is not in our hands to convert. I am just trying to set the point straight in that regard.

Your initial comment was more than just an opinion. You made your comment as a statement of fact. And I wanted to restate the point of the clip which your comment suggests that you missed, namely that "You cannot be tolerant of something unless you object to it".

I would actually be very interested to hear comments along the lines of the quote above than expressions of intolerance on a clip about tolerance. And I don't mean to be reading too much into your comment, I would just...
2-23-2008 6:09 AM
righthand
Is 'whose god' not the question. My Christian god as against your version of him/it. Or his Jewish god as against my Muslim god.

'Converting' in all its guises is the problem. Why can't I make my own way to him if he wants me? Or him/it to me if he wants? It's the interfering third party that causes all the problem. Looking for a shortcut to heaven? Trouble makers.

One thing I do know if ever I find god. It will be a personal god. My business only. No showy hypocrisy, thank you. No beating my chest to show that a great guy I'm.
2-23-2008 11:57 AM
boniface
@willhelm
"You cannot be tolerant of something unless you object to it".
I fully agree with this statement. I don't think I ever said different. What I did say, is that Christians and Muslims find my faith objectionable. I know because they have point blank told me that my God is an abomination in the sight of their God and I just wished for some tolerance on that account.

Now I did say that these two religions attempt to convert the, in their words, "non-believers." I'm afraid that on this point we will just have to disagree. I just did a search for "purpose of missionaries" on Google and Christian organizations that have written out their purpose for their miss...
2-23-2008 1:48 PM
willhelm
I fully agree with this statement. I don't think I ever said different.
What I did say, is that Christians and Muslims find my faith
objectionable. I know because they have point blank told me that my God
is an abomination in the sight of their God and I just wished for some
tolerance on that account.
But how is their (Christians) statement in any way intolorerant. It is no more intolerant of them to believe what they believe than it is for you to believe what you believe (that they should not hold an opinion about your faiht). The only intolerance I see is YOUR intolerance of the fact that Christians have an opinion about your faith, express it, and you attempt to have them...
2-23-2008 8:29 PM
boniface
@willhelm

I suppose the "lynch-pin" of both our arguments is the definition of "convert." Since we disagree on that point, and the whole premise of both our arguments relies on that, we may as well just let it rest. We'll never convince one another.

Thanks for the discussion however.
2-24-2008 2:34 PM
seaj11
Great, more wordplay about "tolerance" so that some Christian nutjob can continue to criticize people who are different from him.

wilhelm and boniface, your discussion seems to be stalled by this same confused definition of "tolerance" the author the clipped article is using, rather than disagreement over conversion. Just an outsider's view.

As for this:
"The opinion that "your god is an abomination" is not intolerant. It is also NOT intolerant to find your faith objectionable.
You obviously find objection to Christianity or you would no doubt be a Christain.
There is nothing wrong with anyone objecting to your faith, or mine. That does not imply intolerance. It would not prevent me from b...
Login to Comment.  Not a member yet? Sign up





Embed This Clip In Your Site...


OK