Clipmarks
jatflafollowshare
8-18-2007 11:46 PM
958 views
jatfla says:
I have not problem with this. PBS puts out stuff that bears no resemblance to what I consider orthodox Christianity all the time. It's just another's religious opinion; whether secular or Islamic. But I agree with Mr. Sookdeo...how would the extremist Muslim's respond in kind? Genuine Christians rest in the truth of their Faith. No longer is there the need or an understanding that there's a Biblical mandate to demand that other's believe as we do.
22 Comments   | Add a Comment
8-19-2007 2:05 AM
The REAL Napster
What about the fact that the Holocaust is denied as well? Maybe PBS could do a 'special' on that as well.
8-19-2007 3:43 AM
medisland
As far as I know, Jesus is a Mesiah in Islam. Also his mother is a saint as per islamic teachings. (unlike what Jews call them if you know what I mean!. ).

Islam is the only religion to believe in both christianity & judaism as true messages once sent by God; Although neither christianity nor judaism believe in Islam.

& yes,
"Jesus is loved and respected by Muslims and he's one of the most important prophets in our religion."
8-19-2007 4:59 AM
manila
Jesus(peace be upon him) is the messiah according to Qur-an(chapter 3, verse 45).
8-19-2007 5:50 AM
SAMIR KHALIL
Yes, you are right: Jesus is THE Messiah in Qur’an 3:45 and is respected (I will not say loved) by Muslims. Jesus is, in the Qur’an, the only prophet who raised the dead. He is the only person elevated to God himself (not only to heaven). He is the only person born from a woman and the Ruh al-Qudus (the Spirit of the Holy = Syriac “Holy Spirit”) without intervention of a man. He is the only one who “created (khalaqa) out of clay the figure of a bird” and “blow upon it and it was a bird” (Qur’an 3:49 and 5:110) as God did. He is the only one “who healed who was born blind and the leper” (same references).
But, Jesus and th...
8-19-2007 10:43 AM
JohnWaterman
I'll certainly be watching. Hooray for British TV
8-19-2007 12:50 PM
AcesLucky
Everyone knows their holy book. Verse by verse. And each one believes theirs is true. But in reality, the relationship they believe they have with a god, is really with a book!

Can any believer gain as small as a simple answer from their god what they do not already know?

If I ask a thousand Muslims, Jews, and Christians each, "the proof of Fermat's last theorem; or the formula for determining the next prime from the last"...

...nary a single person could give an answer. Yet for a god, it should be so simple! WHY can't a god answer these, or any question which the believer does not already know?

The true faith? Simply ask the Muslims (they pray an awful lot) to ask their god a simple q...
8-19-2007 1:12 PM
arifsali
Good clip, wouldn't hurt to see other point of view, you don't have to agree of course.
8-19-2007 1:16 PM
arifsali
BTW, what does it mean by "divine illusion", are they referring to God as some kind of magician who devised a way to fool people?

The proper word should be "divine allegory", Jesus was raised esoterically and merged with the One.
8-19-2007 2:17 PM
jatfla
Yes, the Qur'an recognizes Jesus as the Messiah, but not as the Son of God or the Redeemer and Savior. That's the big difference and it's paramount to Christianity; it's very foundation.
8-19-2007 3:33 PM
arifsali
It just doesn't recognize him as Son of God. All prophets have been redeemers and saviors. Islam stands on the oneness of God hence there is no second or third. God does not beget nor is he begotten.

If I'm not mistaking, not everyone in Christianity take Jesus as Son of God in literal sense.
8-19-2007 4:49 PM
jatfla
Without the deity of Christ, there is no atonement or propitiation for sin.
8-20-2007 1:19 PM
arifsali
Without the deity of Christ, there is no atonement or propitiation for sin.
This is a very subjective statement and a comment to make, won't you agree Ms jatfla?

Here is another comment, tell me what you think: There is no deity except God, the most beneficent, the most merciful. The Lord of the Day of Judgment.

If we equate sin with negative, bad, dark aspect of human psyche then we have to accept that aforementioned cannot exist without their opposite: love, light and positive. And if you agree with this, then you can see that both of these negative and positive qualities belong to God, hence, your statement "there is NO [atonement etc]" seems like contradictory in ...
8-20-2007 11:24 PM
AcesLucky
Here is another comment, tell me what you think: There is no deity except God, the most beneficent, the most merciful. The Lord of the Day of Judgment.
About 26,000 children die the horrific death of starvation EACH DAY. Does a beneficent merciful god hear their prayers?

Hundreds of innocent people get killed each year, (young, old, whatever), by suicide bombers who believes s/he's going to heaven by doing so. Does god hear their prayers?

If there was no god, would the outcome be any different?


If there IS a god, who is truly "the most beneficent, the most merciful"...would not the outcome be different?

It is apparent that one superstit...
8-21-2007 1:27 AM
arifsali
aceslucky, I know where you're coming from so I won't engage in the comments you made above this comment
If there was no god, would the outcome be any different?
. The answer is NO.
8-21-2007 12:08 PM
jatfla
"If there was no god, would the outcome be any different?"

Yes. There would be no anything.

According to *traditional, orthodox Christianity*, Christ is the visible manifestation of the unseen God. Jesus Christ says that He "...and the Father are One" and alludes to His essence in other places. The deity of Jesus Christ and His substitutionary death for humanity are primary tenets of the *orthodox* Christian faith. If He is not who He said He was and He did not do what He said He was sent to do, then He is not a Savior or even a Prophet, but a liar. Believing His own testimony about Himself establishes one's Christianity/Salvation.

Since Christian doctrine has been distorted, supplan...
8-21-2007 3:36 PM
arifsali
Christ is the visible manifestation of the unseen God
Interesting comment, and I can certainly live with that, but I don't see Christ - a historical figure - as a visible manifestation anymore. He could once have been a visible manifestation, but he is certainly not anymore in our life time.

So that takes away the proof. We're now left only with faith. I guess we have enough of that for the world to go around.
8-22-2007 11:53 AM
AcesLucky
"If there was no god, would the outcome be any different?"

Yes. There would be no anything.
---

Supposing your underlying assumptions were true, it could not be the god to whom it was refered, as beneficent and merciful.

Would a Devil allow his own followers to commit atrocities in his name? Would a Devil allow innocent children to suffer horrific deaths of starvation while ignoring their deepest prayers? Would a Devil reward a follower, for killing the innocent with suicide bombs?

Are you sure your underlying assumption, that led you to a "yes," is correct? Because if you are, the truth of your conviction could never distinguish it from ...
9-3-2007 9:48 PM
kinokonoko
Read "The Pegan Christ" by Tom Harpur and you will see that all the stories about Christ are just stories taken from earlier pre-christian pegan religions -- loaves and fishes, 3 wise men, the crusifixion, etc.

9-3-2007 11:57 PM
AcesLucky
Read "The Pegan Christ" by Tom Harpur and you will see that all the stories about Christ are just stories taken from earlier pre-christian pegan religions -- loaves and fishes, 3 wise men, the crusifixion, etc.
Yes. Practically everything.
9-24-2007 9:34 AM
merrie
If they claim they revere Abraham, Isaac, Moses, where
is there any mention of the Ten Commandments in the Quran?
9-24-2007 2:47 PM
arifsali
Ten Commandments are not specifically laid out in Qu'ran exactly as is but there are no injunctions in Qu'ran which negates any of the commandments. So yes, "they" do have faith and belief in Ten Commandments and "they" do revere Abraham, Issac, Moses and rest of the Messengers of God.
10-3-2008 10:50 PM
dandv
If God is so smart, why do you fart?
Login to Comment.  Not a member yet? Sign up
Embed This Clip In Your Site...

New from the makers of Clipmarks:  Amplify.com - Don't just share the news...Amplify it!

OK